A jury in Bexar County, Texas, has ordered the San Antonio restaurant chain Bill Miller Bar-B-Q to pay $2.8 million in damages to a woman who suffered second-degree burns after spilling barbecue sauce on her thigh. Genesis Monita, now 19, was injured in May 2023 when the sauce, described in court as “dangerously hot”, spilt from its container. A jury of six men and six women unanimously found the injuries resulted from the company’s “gross negligence”. They awarded compensatory damages and almost $1.9 million in punitive damages.
Why did a woman sue Bill Miller over hot barbecue sauce
According to the San Antonio Express-News, Ms Monita and her sister went to the Bill Miller restaurant at Old Pearsall Road and Loop 410 on the morning of 19 May 2023 to buy breakfast tacos before school. After buying the food at the drive-thru, Ms Monita pulled into a nearby parking space to eat. She said the sauce was so hot that she dropped the container, spilling it onto her upper right thigh. According to the newspaper, the sauce went through her ripped jeans and left a burn.In her 2023 complaint, Ms Monita alleged that Bill Miller was negligent in giving her “dangerously hot” sauce, in not providing a container that was “adequate” to hold it, and in failing to warn her of the heat, the Express-News reported. The sauce she spilt was 189 degrees, according to the newspaper, which was above the 165 degrees set out in Bill Miller’s policy. Mr McClenahan countered that 165 degrees is a minimum temperature needed to comply with safety rules and that the company has no policy prohibiting heating the sauce to 189 degrees, the Express-News said.
Why did the jury award nearly $1.9 million in punitive damages
Jurors deliberated for just under two hours on Friday before awarding Ms Monita $900,000 for past and future mental anguish, physical pain and impairment. They also awarded $25,225 for medical care expenses and $700 for lost earnings. The newspaper said the verdict included $25,000 for Ms Monita to have surgery to remove a scar left by the burn.After finding gross negligence, the jury had to decide on punitive damages on top of the compensatory award. The Express-News reported that jurors took about 15 minutes to award Ms Monita, who is 19, almost $1.9 million. During the punitive portion of closing arguments, her attorney, Lawrence Morales II, noted that Bill Miller had a net worth of nearly $83 million as of September, according to the newspaper. He first asked the jury to make the company pay 1% of that, almost $830,000, but after hearing Mr McClenahan’s closing arguments, he asked for 10%, or about $8.3 million.
Why did the jury award punitive damages against Bill Miller
Mr Morales told jurors a similar incident had occurred at the same restaurant in 2021, when a woman burned her abdomen after spilling barbecue sauce. He said Bill Miller did not change the way it does business after either incident. Of the award, he said, “It sends the message that companies cannot put profits over customer safety.” Mr McClenahan, according to the newspaper, calculated that in the 865 days between the two incidents the company had dispensed more than 2.2 million ounces of barbecue sauce, giving out 2 ounces in a 4-ounce plastic cup. He said the company knew of no other instances of customers being burned.The company’s history and the wider context. It said Bill Miller started a poultry and egg operation in 1950 and opened a fried chicken to-go restaurant in 1953, later adding hamburgers and barbecue. In 2022, the company announced a $55 million headquarters project on the West Side, which it said would allow it to increase its store count to about 150, according to the Express-News. The newspaper noted that the total award is similar to that in the 1992 McDonald’s coffee case, in which Stella Liebeck, then 79, was awarded $160,000 in compensatory damages and $2.7 million in punitive damages. The case was ultimately settled out of court for less than $500,000.