IND vs NZ 1st Test: Popular or logical? India’s team selection raises questions after Jadeja’s shock exclusion | Cricket News


IND vs NZ 1st Test: Popular or logical? India's team selection raises questions after Jadeja's shock exclusion
Ravindra Jadeja, right, during a practice session in Wellington. (PTI Photo)

Ahead of the fifth T20I against New Zealand in Hamilton earlier this month, India head coach Gautam Gambhir told broadcasters: “My job is not to make everyone happy. My job is to take the right decisions, not the popular decisions. The important thing is to make sure that there is a lot of security inside the dressing room.”Judging by India’s team combination for the first Test against New Zealand at the Basin Reserve, logic appears to have gone missing from the decision-making process as well.Leaving out Mohammed Siraj was one thing. Dropping Ravindra Jadeja was another.Siraj has been India’s leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle with 43 wickets. Jadeja is second on that list with 33. But Jadeja’s value extends well beyond his bowling.He is also India’s third-highest run-getter in this WTC cycle, scoring 790 runs in 11 matches at an average of 60.76. The last time India toured outside the subcontinent, in England in 2025, Jadeja amassed 516 runs in five Tests at an average of 86.His wicket-taking threat may not be what it once was, but he remains a world-class holding bowler and arguably India’s most dependable all-round cricketer. On Day One at Wellington, Washington Sundar performed a containing role. Jadeja could have done that too, while offering significantly more with the bat.As Sunil Gavaskar remarked on commentary: “If you did not want to play him, being such a senior cricketer, why bring him here?”Did Sundar play ahead of Jadeja because New Zealand’s top four comprise left-handers and the management wanted an off-spinner capable of turning the ball away from them?Explaining the call after stumps, batting coach Sitanshu Kotak confirmed: “We preferred Washy as their top order had four left-handers.”The problem with that argument is that Jadeja has built a career troubling left-handers.Of his 356 Test wickets, 120 have been left-handed batters dismissed at an average of 25.75. Among his regular victims are Ben Stokes (eight times), Moeen Ali (seven), Alastair Cook (seven), Matthew Wade (five), David Warner (four) and Usman Khawaja (four).If such a stellar record doesn’t inspire confidence against left-handers, what exactly does?Speaking on his YouTube channel, former India off-spinner R Ashwin questioned the rationale behind leaving out Jadeja.“Left-handers often struggle against left-arm spinners because of the rough that develops outside off stump. Just as left-arm pacers create rough for off-spinners to exploit, this Test features eight right-arm seamers across both teams, most of whom will bowl over the wicket and create rough outside the left-hander’s off stump for Jadeja. In overseas Tests, a spinner’s primary role usually comes into play on Days Four and Five. If Washington Sundar is playing, he is effectively replacing a batter. Jadeja, on the other hand, walks into the side on pure merit. He has been India’s best overseas batter over the last couple of years,” Ashwin stressed.There also seems to be confusion about how India view Nitish Kumar Reddy.The team management has repeatedly spoken about grooming him as a pace-bowling all-rounder for overseas conditions. He was pulled out of the ODI series after the first match and rushed from Auckland to Wellington to prepare for the Tests.Yet when the opportunity arrived, in favourable conditions, he wasn’t picked.This brings us back to Gambhir’s comments about creating security within the dressing room.Players understand being dropped for poor form or when conditions demand a different combination. What they struggle to understand is when messaging of the management and their actions don’t align.If Reddy is genuinely part of India’s long-term overseas plans, shouldn’t he be getting game time? If Jadeja remains one of India’s premier allrounders, why is he sitting out? If Siraj is your leading wicket-taker in the WTC cycle, what exactly was the logic behind excluding him on a green Wellington pitch?Popular decisions don’t always have to be right. But right decisions, at the very least, should be logical.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *