A British mother who turned her life around after years of substance misuse, domestic abuse and mental health difficulties has won another opportunity to challenge the adoption of her young daughter. The woman had completed psychotherapy, remained abstinent from drugs and alcohol, secured stable accommodation and started a new relationship. However, her earlier application to oppose the adoption had been rejected because a Family Court judge considered her progress too recent to demonstrate lasting change.In a judgment dated November 11, 2026, available on BAILII, the Court of Appeal allowed her appeal in G (A Child: Leave to Oppose Adoption) [2026] EWCA Civ 1445. The ruling, delivered by Lord Justice Peter Jackson, with Lord Justice Newey and Lady Justice May agreeing, granted the mother permission to oppose the adoption order. It does not overturn the existing placement order or guarantee that the child will return to her mother. Instead, it allows the adoption application to be contested before the Family Court.
Why the daughter was placed in foster care
The case concerns a girl identified as D, who was around 21 months old when care proceedings began in April 2024. She was placed in foster care after concerns about her mother’s drug and alcohol use, mental health difficulties and relationships with abusive partners.During the original proceedings, the court heard that the mother had experienced serious sexual, physical and emotional abuse during her childhood. She had also faced domestic violence involving three partners in the preceding two years. The Family Court acknowledged her vulnerability, her commitment to rehabilitation and the strong bond she shared with her daughter.However, the judge concluded in March 2025 that the concerns affecting the child’s safety could not be resolved within the girl’s timescale. He refused the mother’s request for a residential assessment and decided that adoption was the only realistic option to meet the child’s long-term welfare needs. A care order and placement order were subsequently made.The last contact between the mother and daughter took place in September 2025. The girl was placed with prospective adopters the following month, and an adoption application was issued in January 2026.
Mother’s rehabilitation and changed circumstances
The mother, who is now 24, later applied for permission to oppose the adoption. In her evidence, she described several significant changes since the original placement order. She said she had remained free from drugs and alcohol since August 2025, supported by regular testing and participation in rehabilitation and recovery services. She had also completed psychotherapy, secured stable accommodation and ended an abusive relationship. She obtained a restraining order against her former partner, who was serving a prison sentence for assaulting her.The mother had also entered a new relationship in August 2025 and began living with her partner in March 2026. Their son was born in May 2026, and she was caring for him without further court proceedings, although he was subject to a Child Protection Plan.The local authority acknowledged that her abstinence was a substantial achievement and accepted that her circumstances had genuinely changed. However, it remained concerned that her recovery and new relationship had not been tested over a sufficiently long period.In August 2026, the Family Court refused her application. The judge considered that her improvements were positive but insufficiently established to demonstrate that they would continue if she also had to care for her daughter. He also emphasised that the child was settled with her prospective adopter and needed stability rather than further uncertainty.
Why the Court of Appeal allowed the mother’s appeal
The mother challenged that decision, arguing that the Family Court had placed too demanding a test on her prospects of opposing adoption and had treated gaps in the available evidence as reasons to reject her application. Lord Justice Peter Jackson agreed. He explained that under Section 47(5) of the Adoption and Children Act 2002, a parent whose child has been placed with prospective adopters under a placement order needs the court’s permission to oppose an adoption. Section 47(7) also requires a change in circumstances since the placement order was made.The Court of Appeal found that the mother had demonstrated genuine and substantial changes. The Family Court should therefore have considered whether she had a sufficiently strong case to deserve a contested hearing, rather than effectively deciding whether she would ultimately win the adoption dispute. The judgment explained that the question was whether the child should have an opposed adoption hearing, not whether adoption itself was in her best interests at that stage. The court also noted that further professional assessments could address unanswered questions about the mother’s partner and rehabilitation arrangements.Importantly, the appeal judges considered that allowing the mother to challenge the adoption could benefit the child in the long term. The decision would shape the girl’s life, and it was important that the possibility of remaining with her birth family had been properly examined.
What happens next?
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and sent the proceedings back to the Family Court for an early case management hearing before a judge nominated by the Family Presiding Judge. Lord Justice Peter Jackson expressly stated that the appeal court was making no decision on the eventual outcome of the adoption application. The Family Court will now consider all the evidence before deciding whether an adoption order should be made.The ruling therefore gives the mother an opportunity to put forward her case, but it does not establish that her daughter will return to her care. The child’s long-term welfare and future family arrangements remain to be determined.