orbit prime news

Second federal judge blocks Trump’s proposed 250-foot Washington arch near Arlington National Cemetery, calling it a rushed job without congressional approval


Second federal judge blocks Trump's proposed 250-foot Washington arch near Arlington National Cemetery, calling it a rushed job without congressional approval

A second federal judge has moved to stop construction of US President Donald Trump’s proposed 250-foot triumphal arch near Arlington National Cemetery, ruling that the project lacked a clear legal basis and had not gone through the proper review process. The decision was delivered on Friday, 20 November 2026, in Alexandria, Virginia. According to Reuters, US District Judge Leonie Brinkema said the administration’s efforts to approve the monument amounted to a “rushed job”. She indicated that she would issue a preliminary injunction blocking construction while the legal challenge continues. The ruling is another setback for Trump’s plan to build a large monument near the historic military cemetery. The proposed arch has faced opposition from local authorities, veterans, preservation groups and residents concerned about its size, location and impact on the surrounding area.The project has become the subject of several legal challenges. Brinkema’s decision follows an earlier ruling by US District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, DC, who temporarily stopped construction on 5 November. Chutkan later extended that restriction until 3 December while considering arguments for a longer-term ban, Reuters reported on 18 November. The Virginia ruling goes further by directly addressing a separate legal challenge brought by Arlington County. It prevents the administration from moving ahead with construction while Brinkema considers the county’s case.

Questions over legal authority and planning

A major issue in the case is whether Trump has the legal power to build the monument without specific approval from Congress. The administration has argued that a law passed in 1925 gives it enough authority to proceed with the project. Brinkema rejected that argument during the hearing. According to Reuters, she questioned the government’s reliance on the century-old law and said the project lacked congressional approval. “It hurts your credibility with the court by focusing on that,” the judge told government lawyers. “This is a project that lacks congressional approval.”The judge also raised concerns about the government’s assessment of the project’s possible effects on the surrounding area. She said federal officials had not properly examined its economic and environmental impact. One particular concern involved nearby Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport. The proposed arch would stand around 3,000 feet from the airport, within its main approach and departure corridor. Although the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) said in September that the structure would not create a danger to aircraft, it required the monument to have a warning light at the top. Floodlights would also have to be directed towards the arch so pilots could see it.Trump has described the proposed structure as a “top-grade Military Complex/Triumphal Arch”. Some aviation experts have raised concerns about its location and possible effects on aircraft operations, Reuters reported. The FAA’s requirements also mean the monument would need permanent lighting, adding another issue to the debate over its impact on the surrounding area.

Community and historical opposition

The size and location of the proposed monument have attracted criticism from local officials and people concerned about the historic setting around Arlington National Cemetery. At 250 feet (76 metres), the arch would be a major addition to the Washington area. Opponents argue that building such a large structure near the cemetery could affect the area’s appearance and the experience of people visiting the site. Arlington County has challenged the federal government’s decision to move ahead with the project. Its legal team argues that the approval process did not properly consider the effects on people who live and work in the area.Kate Talmor, a lawyer at Democracy Forward representing Arlington County, welcomed the Virginia judge’s decision. “We are pleased that the court has recognized the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington and stopped the massive vanity project while our case is heard and considered by the court,” Talmor said, according to Reuters. The opposition has also extended to members of the Kennedy family. Nine family members have joined efforts to stop the construction, arguing that the proposed arch would block views and cast shadows over the graves of their relatives at Arlington National Cemetery.The cemetery is a major national memorial and the resting place of American service members. Opponents believe the proposed structure could change the character of the surrounding landscape. The project has also faced wider criticism over the administration’s decision to move forward while legal challenges remain unresolved.

White House plans to continue defending the project

Despite the latest ruling, the Trump administration has indicated that it will continue fighting to secure approval for the monument. White House spokesman Davis Ingle criticised the legal challenge and defended the proposed structure as a tribute to the country. “The judiciary should not be abused to politicize a structure designed to unite our nation,” Ingle said. “We will continue making the case for this beautiful and fitting monument and are confident we will be fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds.” The White House has indicated that it intends to appeal the Virginia ruling, according to Reuters. The legal dispute forms part of a wider series of court challenges involving Trump’s plans to reshape parts of Washington. Other projects that have faced scrutiny include renovations to the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool and a proposed championship-level golf course about two miles (3.22 kilometres) from the White House.For now, the proposed triumphal arch cannot move forward while the Virginia case is being considered. The separate Washington case also continues, with Judge Chutkan’s temporary order remaining in place until 3 December. The two legal challenges raise questions about the limits of presidential authority over federal land and whether major national monuments can be approved without clear congressional backing. For Arlington County and other opponents, the immediate priority is preventing construction until the courts have fully considered the government’s legal authority and the potential effects of the project. The White House, meanwhile, maintains that the arch is an appropriate national monument and says it will continue defending the plan in court.



Source link

Exit mobile version