orbit prime news

A Welsh glamping-site owner who tried to stop her neighbours driving past their front door to park has been ordered to pay £135,000 in legal costs; she is now challenging the ruling over a disputed driveway


A Welsh glamping-site owner who tried to stop her neighbours driving past their front door to park has been ordered to pay £135,000 in legal costs; she is now challenging the ruling over a disputed driveway

A dispute over a shared driveway in Wales has escalated into a £135,000 legal battle after a glamping-site owner challenged her neighbours’ right to drive a few feet beyond their front door to reach their parking space. According to reports by BBC Wales, The Independent and The Telegraph, Carol Esteban is now appealing a High Court decision that favoured her neighbours, Neil and Nadine Gould, in a row over access rights and an old property document. Esteban, who operates a glamping business at Cwmtawe Farm near Swansea, shares an access track with the Goulds, whose cottage, Cwmtawe Villa, is surrounded by land belonging to the farm. The disagreement centres on how far the couple are legally entitled to travel along the track to reach the parking area beside their home.The disagreement dates back to a property transaction in 1949, when the cottage was separated from the farm under different ownership. Although the original paperwork relating to the sale is no longer available, a conveyancing document drawn up in 1964 established a right of way for the cottage’s owners, allowing them to use the farm’s track on foot or in vehicles. However, the document contained a map that identified the beginning of the permitted route with the letter A but did not clearly mark its endpoint with the corresponding letter B. That missing detail eventually became the central issue in the neighbours’ dispute.Esteban maintained that the access right ended at a point directly opposite the cottage’s front door. She argued that a hedge surrounding the property when the right of way was established would have restricted access to the entrance, rather than extending it to the parking space on the northern side of the house.The Goulds, meanwhile, maintained that their right of way covered the additional stretch needed to reach their parking area. Tensions between the neighbours escalated, with both sides accusing each other of trespassing. Esteban was also accused of obstructing the shared track with large boulders, restricting the couple’s access.The matter eventually reached the High Court in July 2025, where Judge Milwyn Jarman KC ruled in favour of the Goulds. The judge determined that their vehicular access rights extended beyond the line of their front door to the parking space beside the cottage.The ruling took into account the practical implications of Esteban’s interpretation. If the couple could drive only as far as their front entrance, they would have no straightforward way to reach their designated parking area despite the document expressly providing for vehicle access. The court therefore recognised their right to use the track up to the northern side of the property. Esteban was subsequently ordered to pay £135,000 towards the couple’s legal costs.However, the legal dispute is far from over. Esteban has taken the matter to the Court of Appeal in London, challenging both the original decision and the costs order. Representing her, barrister Daniel Bromilow argued that the High Court had not properly interpreted the original property documents and had instead relied on what it considered a reasonable arrangement between the neighbours. He maintained that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the right of way extended beyond the cottage’s front entrance.Her legal team has also challenged the £135,000 costs award, pointing out that Esteban had succeeded on parts of her counterclaim. These included establishing that the Goulds had unlawfully installed a new water pipe on her land, alongside successfully contesting other elements of their case.The Goulds’ representative, Owen Curry, defended the original judgment, arguing that the interpretation adopted by the High Court reflected the intended purpose of the access agreement. He maintained that restricting the route to the front door would make the vehicle access provision largely ineffective.The three appeal judges have reserved their decision, which will be announced at a later date. Until then, the long-running disagreement over a shared driveway, a missing letter on an old map and the extent of property access rights remains unresolved.



Source link

Exit mobile version