orbit prime news

A UK customer bought a £379 laptop online, switched it on and was denied a refund because he had activated Windows 11; after fighting Argos without a lawyer, he won a Court of Appeal ruling two years later


A UK customer bought a £379 laptop online, switched it on and was denied a refund because he had activated Windows 11; after fighting Argos without a lawyer, he won a Court of Appeal ruling two years later

A University of Leicester academic who represented himself in court has won a legal battle against retail giant Argos in the Court of Appeal. The ruling protects online shoppers who switch on new laptops to check whether they work before deciding to return them. In a judgment issued on 13 November 2026 in the case of Adodo v Argos Limited, three senior judges unanimously ruled that activating pre-installed Windows 11 software does not remove a buyer’s legal right to cancel an online purchase and receive a full refund. The decision ends a two-year legal dispute over a £379 Lenovo IdeaPad laptop. It also orders Argos to return the full purchase price, along with interest calculated from 14 days after the customer first tried to return the laptop in September 2024.

How the refund dispute started

According to the official judgment published by The National Archives, Dr Ebenezer Adodo ordered a Lenovo IdeaPad 1 laptop bundle from the Argos website on 31 August 2024. He also bought a mouse pad priced at £9.99. The total cost was £388.99, which he paid by card. He selected the retailer’s click-and-collect service and chose to collect the items from an Argos desk inside his local Sainsbury’s store. Dr Adodo collected the products later that day and took them home. He switched on the laptop to check whether it met the IT requirements for his work. However, he soon found that the computer had compatibility problems with software he used at the University of Leicester. The mouse pad was also too large for his desk.He put both products back into their original boxes and took them to the Sainsbury’s collection point on 5 September 2024, just five days after buying them. However, staff refused to refund the laptop. They told him that Argos’ terms and conditions did not allow returns once a box had been opened and a laptop had been switched on.

The journey through the courts

Dr Adodo filed a small claim at Leicester County Court under the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013. These rules give people who buy products online 14 days to cancel their orders without having to explain why. As explained in the Court of Appeal judgment, Argos first argued that click-and-collect purchases did not count as “distance contracts” under the 2013 regulations. A district judge accepted the retailer’s argument and dismissed Dr Adodo’s claim.Dr Adodo appealed the decision. At the first appeal, His Honour Judge Hedley overturned the earlier ruling. He found that the sales contract had been made online when Argos confirmed the order by email. The fact that the customer collected the products from a store did not change this. Judge Hedley ordered Argos to refund the £9.99 mouse pad but agreed with the retailer over the laptop. Argos relied on a witness statement from Lauren Hunt, a legal assistant at Sainsbury’s Group. The retailer argued that switching on the laptop and activating Windows 11 had broken a “digital seal”. Judge Hedley accepted this argument and ruled that an exemption under Regulation 28(3)(b) applied. This provision removes the right to cancel a purchase of sealed computer software once the seal has been broken after delivery.

Why the Court of Appeal rejected the digital seal argument

Dr Adodo decided to challenge the ruling again, this time representing himself against Argos’ legal team from Sainsbury’s. He took the case to the Court of Appeal in London on 4 November 2026. Lady Justice Andrews, Lady Justice King and Lord Justice Foxton unanimously ruled in his favour and allowed the appeal. In the main judgment, Lady Justice Andrews explained that Dr Adodo had purchased a computer with pre-installed software, not a separate package of sealed computer software.“The contract was a contract for the supply of a computer which was preloaded with an operating system to make it functional. It was not a contract for the supply of ‘sealed computer software’ within the meaning of Regulation 28(3)(b),” Lady Justice Andrews wrote in the ruling. She also warned that accepting Argos’ interpretation of the law would seriously weaken consumer protection for people buying electronic products online.“Argos’ expansive interpretation of that provision would deprive a consumer of the right to cancel almost any contract for the sale of a computer, phone or other electronic gadget which has operating software pre-installed, as most such items do, as soon as the consumer switched on the item and set the software running. Given that many items of that nature are bought online, that would seriously undermine the protection afforded to consumers by the Regulations,” the judgment noted.

What the ruling means for shoppers and retailers

Legal analysts at Solicitor News and Home of Direct Commerce noted that the decision confirms that click-and-collect purchases carry the same 14-day cancellation rights as products delivered directly to a customer’s home. The Court of Appeal also explained that customers shopping in physical stores are allowed to inspect and test display products before buying them. Online shoppers should have a similar opportunity to check the products they receive.Under Regulation 34 of the 2013 rules, retailers can reduce a refund if a customer handles a product beyond what is necessary to check its nature, features and how it works. This allows businesses to deduct an amount if the product has lost value because of excessive handling. However, Lady Justice Andrews pointed out that Argos had not provided evidence showing that switching on the laptop had reduced its value. The retailer had also failed to prove that it had faced any specific costs to reset the computer.The ruling could lead retailers across the UK to review their return policies, particularly rules that automatically reject refunds for electronics bought online simply because customers have opened the packaging or switched on the device. The decision makes clear that activating pre-installed software does not, by itself, remove a shopper’s legal right to cancel an online computer purchase within the 14-day cooling-off period.



Source link

Exit mobile version