A Wisconsin couple who sued their neighborhood association for a fence so their five children could play safely won $200,000, and now they are suing 33 neighbors who never paid their $1,350 share


A Wisconsin couple who sued their neighborhood association for a fence so their five children could play safely won $200,000, and now they are suing 33 neighbors who never paid their $1,350 share

A backyard fence intended to protect five children has turned into a costly legal dispute in a Wisconsin neighbourhood, with a family now taking its homeowners association and dozens of residents back to court. Lisa and Michael Newman of De Pere, Wisconsin, secured a $200,000 settlement after their neighbourhood association refused to let them build a fence around their property. Now, nearly two years after the settlement, the couple is pursuing unpaid contributions from residents who have not paid their assigned share. The latest development was reported by Realtor dot com and NBC 26, which have followed the dispute since it first reached federal court. The original disagreement began in 2019, when the Newmans approached the Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association (NTPOA) seeking permission to install a fence around their backyard. The couple wanted a secure outdoor space where their five children, all diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, could play without the risk of wandering away.Some of the children had additional medical complexities, and the family believed a fenced yard would make outdoor activities safer while allowing them greater independence. However, the association rejected their request, citing a restrictive covenant dating back to the subdivision’s 2001 plat map, which prohibited fences of any kind. The family subsequently sought legal assistance from Disability Rights Wisconsin and filed a federal lawsuit against the association in August 2021, alleging disability discrimination under the Fair Housing Amendments Act.In May 2022, US District Judge William Griesbach granted the family a preliminary injunction preventing the association from enforcing its no-fence rule against them. The decision allowed the Newmans to finally install the fence, approximately three years after their initial request. The legal battle, however, continued beyond the construction of the backyard barrier.

A $200,000 settlement divided among homeowners

In August 2024, the Newmans and the association reached a settlement requiring NTPOA to pay the family $200,000. The financial responsibility was distributed among the neighbourhood’s property owners, with each household expected to contribute $1,350 towards the settlement.The arrangement did not sit well with everyone in the subdivision. Several residents later told NBC 26 that they had not been consulted about the original fence dispute and were unhappy about being asked to contribute towards a legal settlement involving a decision made by the association’s board. Some homeowners also maintained that they would have supported the family’s request had they been given an opportunity to express their views before the matter escalated.According to the Newmans’ attorney, Victoria Davis Dávila, 69 homeowners have settled their outstanding contributions. However, 55 homeowners still owe money, prompting the family to initiate another legal proceeding this autumn.Thirty-three neighbours named in the new lawsuitThe latest lawsuit names the property owners’ association and 33 residents who have not paid their assigned contributions. The distinction is important because the 55 figure represents the number of homeowners the family’s attorney says still owe money, while 33 residents are named in the new filing.The Newmans are seeking to enforce the outstanding payment obligations rather than revisit the original dispute over the fence. The development has once again unsettled residents, particularly those who have already paid their $1,350 share. Some homeowners fear that if the association cannot recover the remaining money, the entire membership could potentially face further financial liability.The association has filed an answer and affirmative defence dated November 16, 2026, according to Realtor dot com. The contents of the filing were not publicly available when the publication reported on the case.

A neighbourhood still divided

The renewed legal action has brought back tensions among residents of Nazcr Trac, with some questioning why individual homeowners should bear the financial consequences of decisions made by the association’s former leadership. For the Newmans, however, the dispute stems from a request they made to provide their children with a safer environment at home. Their attorney has indicated that the family wants the outstanding settlement obligations resolved so everyone involved can move on.What began as a disagreement over a neighbourhood’s restrictions on backyard fencing has consequently developed into a much larger dispute involving disability accommodation, homeowners’ association responsibilities and the financial obligations of residents. With another lawsuit now underway, the five-year-old fence dispute continues to have consequences for the entire De Pere community.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *