A London woman took her neighbours to court after they allegedly forced her garden gate twice and changed its lock; a judge ordered a father and son to pay £20,000 in legal costs | World News


A London woman took her neighbours to court after they allegedly forced her garden gate twice and changed its lock; a judge ordered a father and son to pay £20,000 in legal costs

A London woman who withdrew permission for neighbours to use a passageway leading to a shared garden over privacy concerns has secured an interim court order after a dispute involving allegations of trespass and harassment. Musician Jodie Schloss took legal action against a father and son after the gate to the passageway was allegedly forced open twice and its lock changed without her knowledge. The row at a residential property in Swiss Cottage also involved the family leaving their laundry to dry on her private patio. Judge Stephen Hellman ordered the two men to pay approximately £20,000 in legal costs and accepted legally binding undertakings preventing them from entering her passageway or patio without permission.

Jodie Schloss objected to neighbours walking past her front door

According to The Independent, the claimant was musician Jodie Schloss, who lives in a garden flat at a Victorian villa in Strathray Gardens, Swiss Cottage. The passageway runs alongside her property and provides access to the garden at the rear of the building. For around 30 years, residents of other flats had also used the route to reach the garden, with Schloss having previously provided them with keys.However, the arrangement changed in August 2025 when Schloss withdrew her consent for other residents to use the passageway, citing privacy concerns. Her barrister, John Clargo, told the court that she no longer wanted people walking so close to her front door, describing it as an “invasion of her sense of privacy”. Although other residents had previously used the route, Clargo argued that they did not have a right to use either the passageway or the garden. Robin Larkins, one of the neighbours involved in the dispute, had his own direct access to the garden through the back door of his flat.

Dispute escalated after neighbours allegedly damaged gate and changed its lock

The disagreement intensified after Schloss withdrew permission. Clargo told the court that on 1 September 2025, Derek Larkins insisted he had a right to use the passageway, while his son Robin threatened to rip out the gate. Schloss subsequently discovered damage to the lock and, after returning to collect her belongings on 6 September, found further damage. Her barrister said CCTV footage led her to believe Robin had been responsible for the later damage.Clargo also told the court that Robin changed the lock on the gate on 2 October 2025 without providing Schloss with a key, despite a request from her solicitor. She subsequently changed the locks back. On 22 March 2026, Derek allegedly forced the lock, and the two men used the passageway on that date and again on 24 March. The dispute also involved an incident on 9 April 2026, when laundry belonging to Robin Larkins’ family was hung out to dry on Schloss’s private patio. Robin said his cleaner had put the washing there without realising and had been told not to repeat it.

London woman sought injunction to stop neighbours entering her property

Schloss brought proceedings alleging trespass and harassment and sought an injunction to prevent further incursions onto her property. During the hearing, Robin Larkins represented himself and argued that the dispute was about protecting the other leaseholders’ access to the communal garden. He told the judge that he had direct access to the garden from his own flat, but believed the other residents should also be able to use it because they had enjoyed access for 30 years and contributed towards its maintenance through their service charges.After a three-hour hearing, Judge Stephen Hellman, sitting at Mayor’s and City County Court, accepted legally binding undertakings from Derek and Robin Larkins not to enter Schloss’s passageway or patio again without permission, pending a full trial. The judge said he could understand how Schloss’s letter withdrawing access must have come as a shock to the other residents. However, he also noted that the conduct involving the forced gate justified a substantial costs order.

Court ordered father and son to pay around £20,000 in legal costs

According to Gatehouse Chambers, the court ordered the defendants to pay approximately £20,000 in legal costs and found that the forced entry to the passageway justified an order on the indemnity basis, despite the hearing concerning an application for interim relief. The chambers said the judge granted relief in the claimant’s favour after hearing evidence of two occasions when the gate was forced, and the lock was changed without her knowledge.The undertakings mean that Derek and Robin Larkins are legally bound not to enter Schloss’s passageway or patio without her permission. However, the dispute has not yet reached a full trial. The case is due to return to court at a later date unless the parties settle first. Judge Hellman also warned the defendants that they could face substantially higher legal costs if they continued to contest the case and ultimately lost.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *