A property deal worth $272,500 fell through after a Missouri couple could not get a mortgage released that they said had already been paid off. The former sellers refused to drop their financial claim on the property, insisting that some payments were still owed. A court has now backed a $47,500 damages award against them. The Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, ruled on November 17, 2026, that the evidence backed the original decision in favor of Joseph C. Barber and Brenda L. Barber. The court found that Kimberly R. Weger had no valid financial reason to block the sale after the loan had been paid off. The ruling also upheld a separate legal penalty of $3,732.50, plus $28,065.77 in legal fees and court costs. The appeals court also sent the case back to the lower court to decide on extra legal fees from the appeal. The fight centered on a property at 4905 West Route F in Clark, Missouri, and focused on a dispute over payments made almost ten years before the planned sale.
Property purchase and original mortgage agreement
According to the court’s opinion in Joseph C. Barber and Brenda L. Barber v. Kimberly R. Weger, the Barbers bought the property from Kimberly Weger and her husband, Aubrey Weger, in 2006. The buyers signed a loan agreement for $37,325 to cover part of the purchase price. A deed of trust was also filed in favor of the Wegers on November 22, 2006, giving them a legal claim over the property until the loan was paid in full. Under the terms, the Barbers had to pay $450 a month toward the loan and interest. Payments started on December 1, 2006, and ran until November 2015, when the loan ended. The deal also included a $25 late fee if a monthly payment arrived after the 15th of the month. Brenda Barber later testified that the couple made all the required payments, including any late fees. She said they believed the debt was completely settled.
$272,500 sale put on hold
In April 2022, the Barbers signed a deal to sell the property for $272,500. The closing date was set for May 13 of that year. Before the sale could close, they learned that the deed of trust in favor of the Wegers was still listed against the property. The former sellers refused to clear it, saying they had not received every monthly payment, especially those from 2014 and 2015. They also refused to give a final payoff figure showing how much they thought was still owed. The court’s account notes that Aubrey told Brenda she “couldn’t sell the Property” because the Barbers “didn’t own it”. He also said he would “stop the sale” because he “really wish[ed] they had the house and property back.” Their son, Ashtin Weger, also told Brenda that he “would do whatever it took and make sure people knew [the Plaintiffs] didn’t own [the Property] and couldn’t sell it”, because he wanted his “parents to have” the property. The Barbers pushed back the closing date three times and dropped the sale price to $225,000 to try to save the deal. The original sale still collapsed because the deed of trust remained on the record.
Legal demand failed to secure mortgage release
After the refusal, the Barbers hired a lawyer to get the deed of trust removed. On May 5, 2022, their lawyer sent an official demand letter under Section 443.130 of Missouri law. It asked the Wegers to sign and file a release document and either return the canceled loan agreement or sign a sworn statement confirming the debt was paid. The letter included bank records showing most of the payments made in 2014 and 2015. The Barbers explained that some older receipts were missing because almost seven years had passed and several payments were made by money order. They also sent money for the filing fees and prepared the forms for the Wegers to sign. The first letter came back after the Wegers refused to accept it. The Barbers’ lawyer then sent the same papers through the Wegers’ attorney. The buyers also offered to put any disputed money into a secure holding account so the sale could go ahead. The Wegers still refused to give a payoff amount or release the deed of trust. The Barbers then filed a lawsuit in Boone County Circuit Court on August 19, 2022.
Former sellers disputed payment records
During the trial, Brenda maintained that she and Joseph made every payment owed under the loan. She explained that they did not save every receipt because they thought the loan was finished. Once the Wegers questioned the payments, she reached out to banks to find old records. The banks could not find proof for six monthly payments from 2014 and 2015. Even so, the Barbers showed the records they were able to get. Kimberly told a different story. She testified that her records showed only 67 of the 107 required payments were made, leaving $17,079.97 unpaid, not counting late fees. She also said she still had the payment records despite a 2017 house fire. According to her testimony, the home office where she kept the files was the only room that did not burn. Kimberly said she did not mean to block the sale and claimed she could not force Aubrey to sign the release. She also testified that she would forgive the unpaid balance if she got a right-of-way agreement across the property. That deal never happened.
Court finds refusal to release deed unjustified
In June 2024, the trial judge issued a partial ruling ordering the deed of trust to be cleared. The remaining claims for money damages were handled separately. Once the legal hold was lifted, the Barbers finally sold the property for $225,000 on September 16, 2024. In May 2025, the Boone County Circuit Court ruled in their favor on the remaining claims. It granted them $3,732.50 under Missouri’s mortgage-release law, plus $28,065.77 in legal fees and court costs. The court also awarded $47,500 for wrongfully interfering with a real estate sale.Kimberly appealed, claiming there was not enough proof that the loan was paid off or that her refusal to release the deed was unfair. The Missouri Court of Appeals turned down both arguments. In its November 17 opinion, the appeals court said the trial judge had the right to believe Brenda’s testimony and the bank records as proof that the payments were finished. It also noted that the trial judge was responsible for deciding which witnesses were believable.The judges also ruled that a lender’s financial claim on a deed of trust ends as soon as the debt is paid in full. The court noted that the Wegers refused to give a payoff figure despite repeated requests. It also looked at evidence showing their refusal was driven by a wish to stop the Barbers from selling the property because they wanted it back. The appeals judges decided that the refusal was not backed by a valid financial interest.
Additional legal fees to be decided
The court upheld the original ruling, including the $47,500 damages award and the statutory payment. It also approved the Barbers’ request for extra legal fees built up after the first ruling and during the appeal. Instead of setting the amount itself, the Missouri Court of Appeals sent the case back to the Boone County Circuit Court to figure out fair post-judgment and appeal legal costs. The November 17 ruling was issued in case WD88284, with Judges Cynthia L. Martin, Lisa White Hardwick, and Gary D. Witt serving on the panel. The decision leaves the $47,500 award standing and requires Kimberly Weger to face another review of the Barbers’ legal bills.